Supreme Court justice rejects PSB's and PSBD's motions against Lula appointment

- 05 de Abril por EBC

Supreme Court (STF) Justice Teori Zavascki rejected Monday (Apr. 4) the motions filed by PSB and PSDB parties against the president's decree appointing former President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva as chief-of-staff. To his understanding, actions against the violation of a constitutional fundamental right, known in Portuguese as ADPFs, do not apply in the arguments presented.

The justice argues a citizen suit or a public interest civil action could be lodged instead. “What is made clear after all these considerations is that, as a solution to the legal problem outlined in the ADPF, more than one alternate mechanism to reach the court was available which was capable to produce an advantageous response—effective and immediate,” Zavascki says in his ruling.

He notes that the writ of mandamus was used by both the PPS and the PSBD to question Lula's nomination, and that it was in Justice Gilmar Mendes's provisional ruling on this appeal that Justice Gilmar Mendes invalidated Lula's appointment on March 18, so Gilmar's decision is still in effect, despite Zavascki's decision—and Lula's cabinet post remains suspended.

Zavascki further highlights that, in the two motions turned down today, the parties maintain that, by nominating the former president as minister after the release of “related accounts linking [Lula's] name to wrongdoing for which he was being investigated by the Federal Court in Curitiba, the president was allegedly attempting to grant him privileged forum, arbitrarily transferring the jurisdiction investigating him.” The political parties also ask for “the jurisdiction of the natural judge in the case in question [to be] preserved,” i.e., Federal Judge Sérgio Moro's.

In the text of his ruling, the minster also describes that the target of the two motions as “an isolated uncommon and unprecedented act by the presidency, whereby former President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva was named so as to  occupy a cabinet position. No analogous case has been known, nor has the probability of its recurrence outside of theory.”

mais populares
edição online
- 14 de Junho - ESPORTES

Rússia surpreende e goleia a Arábia Saudita na estreia da Copa

Os donos da casa abriram a Copa do Mundo com uma goleada sobre a Arábia Saudita. Desacreditada por resultados ruins em sua preparação para o torneio,...

- 14 de Junho - BRASIL

Paulo Henrique Amorim é condenado pelo STF em caso de injúria racial

O jornalista Paulo Henrique Amorim foi condenado por crime de injúria racial pela Terceira Turma Criminal do Tribunal de Justiça do Distrito Federal....

- 13 de Junho - ESPORTES

Espanha demite técnico dois dias antes de estreia na Copa

Faltando apenas dois dias para a estreia da seleção da Espanha na Copa do Mundo, a Real Federação Espanhola de Futebol demitiu nesta quarta-feira o...

Guia Comercial

Os melhores negócios e empresas você só encontra aqui.

Anuncie grátis aqui !